Our menu rotates seasonally and as creativity strikes. Pop in to the shop to pick up a treat to-go, or use this page to order for pick-up more than 48 hours in advance. If you have any questions, give us a call at (312) 667-0108!
17.00
Your favorite flavors got all dressed up for Halloween!
In this pack you'll find a Chocolate Mummy, Pancake Spider, Breakfast in Lima Black Cat, and Pumpkin Spice Jack-O-Lantern.
0.00
Calling all cookie monsters! Our new Cookie Lover's cake has layers of a delicious brown sugar chocolate chip cake, filled with chocolatey crinkle cookie buttercream, covered with a sweet soy candied pecan caramel. To top off each layer, you can enjoy chocolate chip, brown butter spiced pecan, and crinkle cookie crumbles. Never struggle to choose between cookies or cake again-- this cake takes "cookie cake" to a whole new level!
allergies: nuts, gluten, eggs
0.00
Our caramel apple cake takes your tastebuds back to your childhood fall festival! With layers of sweet and cinnamon-y apples between layers of a spiced caramel cake and a gingerbread caramel butter cream, it's the perfect cake to cozy into the fall!
allergies: gluten, eggs, dairy, cinnamon
0.00
It's a bird! It's a plane! No! It's a pie in the sky!
This mouth-watering pie in the sky cake taste like a delicious bite of a classic thanksgiving pie. This graham cracker cake is topped and layered with brown butter buttercream, filled with sweet cranberry jam, and finished off with a delicious pie crust crumble.
0.00
Nothing says fall like a pumpkin spice latte, and what's better than a pumpkin spice latte?! A pumpkin spice latte cake! Moist pumpkin cake, espresso buttercream and warm fall spices wake you up from that cold weather stupor. Like your favorite fall sweater-- but for your taste buds!
50.00
reservation must be confirmed with the restaurant in order to place a pre-order.
we *love* celebrations at girl & the goat, little goat diner, cabra, and duck duck goat and want to get sugargoat in on the fun! pre-order a 6-inch cake with us, and we'll have it ready for dessert and brought to your table.
*please choose 12 pm as your pick up time.
60.00
reservation must be confirmed with the restaurant in order to place a pre-order.
we *love* celebrations at girl & the goat, little goat diner, cabra, and duck duck goat and want to get sugargoat in on the fun! pre-order a 6-inch cake with us, and we'll have it ready for dessert and brought to your table.
*please choose 12 pm as your pick up time.
0.00
like a spoonful of peanut butter but better
contains: dairy, gluten, eggs, peanuts
55.00
Boo! Get into the spooky spirit with our yummy Halloween cakes!
Get wrapped up in our devil's food mummy cake, with layers of rich chocolate cake and scary-good vanilla buttercream
If you already love our Tie Dye-vanilla cake, just wait till you try our Spooky Tie Dye cake! The "sweetest" spider you'll ever meet ;)
0.00
You've heard about ice cream cake, but what about ice cream pie? Chocolate cookie crumble crust with our house made cookies and cream ice cream swirled inside, topped off with our chocolate crinkle cookies. What more could you want?
48.00
12 of your choice of our delicious, fluffy bagels - great for breakfast or any time of day!
24.00
6 of your choice of our delicious, fluffy bagels - great for breakfast or any time of day!
0.00
With a delicate layer of icing and gooey chocolate center, these crinkle clouds melt in your mouth.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
You know the deal!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
Balancing spicy pecan and melty butter with a sweet soy drizzle, these cookies are surprising - but not surprisingly, they're delicious.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, pecans, soy
0.00
Gooey pickled raisins, crunchy oatmeal, allllll cookie.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
33.00
It's officially that time of year when all of your favorite desserts are pumpkin flavored! Our revamped pumpkin pie is topped with candied This Little Goat Mexico crunch, and is sure to become your seasonal go-to!
0.00
It's buttery, its cheesy, its cakey, and its also kind of a pie?! All you really need to know is it's delicious... especially served with our seasonal jam!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
This pie is a marriage of your favorite sweet and savory combo: chocolate and french fries! With silky malt filling and a fry crumble crust, this party in your mouth is best served cold.
Contains: dairy, gluten egg, potatoes
0.00
Silky bittersweet filling. Chocolate cookie crumble crust. Chocolate Caramel. Chocolate brittle. Need we say more? Keep refrigerated, serve cold.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
What do you get when you combine lime and orange into a silky and citrus-y curd filling and top it with dollops of toasted meringue in a chocolate shortbread crust? Citrus Meringue Pie! It's like sunshine in a pie, orange you glad you asked?
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
This isn't your grandma's pecan pie. With the surprising flavor of Chef Stephanie's This Little Goat went to Tokyo sauce and shortbread, every pecan-y, creamy bite is complex and delightful.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, pecans
0.00
It's the apple pie you know and love, with a cheesy-caramel-y twist. Sprinkled with our little goat India spice., this pie provides a full experience for your taste buds! Serve at room temp or gently warmed in a 300 degree oven.
Contains: dairy, gluten, cinnamon
45.00
Flavor bomb! Tahini-infused marble cake lathered in über creamy tahini-vanilla buttercream all topped with sesame-chocolate-caramel and crunchy sesame-chocolate crumble... this cake has it all.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, sesame
45.00
Calling all chocoholics! Chocolate cake, chocolate sauce, chocolate buttercream, chocolate crumble... chocolate everything!
What more could you really want?
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
45.00
Like your grandma's lemon bars... but in cake form and way better! Lemon, lime and orange zest, layers of lemon curd and vanilla buttercream make this refreshing sweet treat like a summer's day!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
45.00
It's got veggies in it... so it's healthy - right? Just ignore the cream cheese... ok, maybe don't! Indulge in this delight made of moist carrot cake spiced with This Little Goat went to India and perfectly coated in rich cream cheese frosting!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, cinnamon
45.00
Take your tastebuds on a vacation with our most exotic cake creation! A sweet and savory plantain cake base (think banana bread, only better, layered with a coffee-lime caramel filling and chocolate ganache. Finished with a coffee-lime buttercream chocolate crunch.
*Limited time
Contains: dairy, gluten egg, coffee
45.00
Cake for breakfast? Pancakes for dessert? Whichever way you swing it... enjoy the flavor of your morning-time favorite dish with this sourdough pancake cake with maple buttercream and an oat streusel topping.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, cinnamon
45.00
Chef Steph's favorite snack? Cheez-Its! Cheez-it cake, cheddar caramel, strawberry nesquik buttercream, cheddar caramel buttercream, and cheez-it crunch. You'll be addicted!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
45.00
Get groovy with tye-dye cake with brightly-colored vanilla buttercream a colorful swirl inside
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
25.50
Choose your favorite flavor!
Contains: All contain dairy, gluten, egg; Cheez-it cupcake also contains peanuts; Breakfast in Lima cupcake contains stone fruit
Beginning 10/15 through the month of October, all cupcakes will be decorated Halloween-themed unless specifically requested otherwise!
17.00
Choose your favorite flavor!
Contains: All contain dairy, gluten, egg; Cheez-it cupcake also contains peanuts; Breakfast in Lima cupcake contains stone fruit
Beginning 10/15 through the month of October, all cupcakes will be decorated Halloween-themed unless specifically requested otherwise!
51.00
Choose your favorite flavor!
Contains: All contain dairy, gluten, egg; Cheez-it cupcake also contains peanuts; Breakfast in Lima cupcake also contains stone fruit
Beginning 10/15 through the month of October, all cupcakes will be decorated Halloween-themed unless specifically requested otherwise!
50.00
Pick two flavors our rotating ice cream and we'll create you a tasty frozen treat! Ice Cream cakes are 6".
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
Choose your favorite flavor, we've got it all from fan favorites to funky!
