Our menu rotates seasonally and as creativity strikes. Pop in to the shop to pick up a treat to-go, or use this page to order for pick-up more than 48 hours in advance. If you have any questions, give us a call at (312) 667-0108!
50.00
the only thing better than treats that look like flowers - is flowers themselves! gift your mom sugargoat's seasonal four-pack of cupcakes alongside a bouquet from bottle & branch for the sweetest, freshest mother's day!
55.00
gift or celebrate the mom (or mother figure!) in your life with our citrus cake, layered with blueberry jam, and adorned with a bouquet of buttercream blooms.
pre-order now for pick-up 5/5 - 5/9!
35.00
all moms and mother-figures deserve flowers. all moms and mother-figures deserve cookies. why not give both, all in one?!
pre-order now for pick-up 5/5 - 5/9!
28.00
one each of citrus, blueberry, chocolate and tie dye - all dressed up in buttercream flowers!
pre-order now for pick-up 5/5 - 5/9!
0.00
can this count as a serving of veggies?! our rhubarb pie has a delicate rhubarb center, topped with cheez-it crumble and ooey-gooey caramel.
45.00
We’re having breakfast for dessert with our Lucky Cereal Cake! This layered trip to childhood has malted buttercream sandwiched between vanilla cake, and is, of course, topped with colorful marshmallows!
Lucky cereal cake, malt butter buttercream, mini marshmallows, and shortbread crumble
Contains gluten, dairy, eggs, and food coloring
0.00
You've heard about ice cream cake, but what about ice cream pie? Chocolate cookie crumble crust with our house made cookies and cream ice cream swirled inside, topped off with our chocolate crinkle cookies. What more could you want?
48.00
12 of your choice of our delicious, fluffy bagels - great for breakfast or any time of day!
24.00
6 of your choice of our delicious, fluffy bagels - great for breakfast or any time of day!
54.00
By the dozen. Choose one of our ready-to-go favorite themes, or submit your own creative cookie ideas through our Special Orders section!
Contains: dairy, gluten egg
0.00
You know the deal!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
With a delicate layer of icing and gooey chocolate center, these crinkle clouds melt in your mouth.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
Balancing spicy pecan and melty butter with a sweet soy drizzle, these cookies are surprising - but not surprisingly, they're delicious.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, pecans, soy
0.00
Gooey pickled raisins, crunchy oatmeal, allllll cookie.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
It's buttery, its cheesy, its cakey, and its also kind of a pie?! All you really need to know is it's delicious... especially served with our marmalade!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
This pie is a marriage of your favorite sweet and savory combo: chocolate and french fries! With silky malt filling and a fry crumble crust, this party in your mouth is best served cold.
Contains: dairy, gluten egg, potatoes
0.00
Silky bittersweet filling. Chocolate cookie crumble crust. Chocolate Caramel. Chocolate brittle. Need we say more? Keep refrigerated, serve cold.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
What do you get when you combine lime and orange into a silky and citrus-y curd filling and top it with dollops of toasted meringue in a chocolate shortbread crust? Citrus Meringue Pie! It's like sunshine in a pie, orange you glad you asked?
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
This isn't your grandma's pecan pie. With the surprising flavor of Chef Stephanie's This Little Goat went to Tokyo sauce and shortbread, every pecan-y, creamy bite is complex and delightful.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, pecans
40.00
Flavor bomb! Tahini-infused marble cake lathered in über creamy tahini-vanilla buttercream all topped with sesame-chocolate-caramel and crunchy sesame-chocolate crumble... this cake has it all.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, sesame
40.00
Calling all chocoholics! Chocolate cake, chocolate sauce, chocolate buttercream, chocolate crumble... chocolate everything!
What more could you really want?
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
40.00
Cake for breakfast? Pancakes for dessert? Whichever way you swing it... enjoy the flavor of your morning-time favorite dish with this sourdough pancake cake with maple buttercream and an oat streusel topping.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, cinnamon
40.00
Like your grandma's lemon bars... but in cake form and way better! Lemon, lime and orange zest, layers of lemon curd and vanilla buttercream make this refreshing sweet treat like a summer's day!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
40.00
It's got veggies in it... so it's healthy - right? Just ignore the cream cheese... ok, maybe don't! Indulge in this delight made of moist carrot cake spiced with This Little Goat went to India and perfectly coated in rich cream cheese frosting!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, cinnamon
40.00
Take your tastebuds on a vacation with our most exotic cake creation! A sweet and savory plantain cake base (think banana bread, only better, layered with a coffee-lime caramel filling and chocolate ganache. Finished with a coffee-lime buttercream chocolate crunch.
*Limited time
Contains: dairy, gluten egg, coffee
40.00
Chef Steph's favorite snack? Cheez-Its! Cheez-it cake, cheddar caramel, strawberry nesquik buttercream, cheddar caramel buttercream, and peanut butter cheez-it crunch. You'll be addicted!
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg, peanuts
0.00
Get groovy with tye-dye cake dyed with au-natural and organic dyes complete with vanilla buttercream and tasty shortbread crumble.
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
17.00
Choose your favorite flavor!
Contains: All contain dairy, gluten, egg; Cheez-it cupcake also contains peanuts; Breakfast in Lima cupcake contains stone fruit
51.00
Choose your favorite flavor!
Contains: All contain dairy, gluten, egg; Cheez-it cupcake also contains peanuts; Breakfast in Lima cupcake also contains stone fruit
40.00
Pick two flavors our rotating ice cream and we'll create you a tasty frozen treat! Ice Cream cakes are 6".
Contains: dairy, gluten, egg
0.00
Choose your favorite flavor, we've got it all from fan favorites to funky!
0.00
0.00
